Subscribe now

The Great Christ Comet

By Colin R Nicholl
April 2016 | Review by William Worraker
  • Publisher: Crossway
  • ISBN: 978-1-4335-4213-8
  • Pages: 368
  • Price: 16.99
Buy this book »

Book Review

Most attempts to develop a coherent, astronomical story behind the Star of Bethlehem have been made by astronomers with limited respect for Scripture. The results have been disappointing.

In contrast, Colin Nicholl treats Scripture with care and respect, paying attention to detail and dealing accurately with astronomy. The book is beautifully illustrated, well written, well researched and amply referenced.

Using Matthew’s birth narrative as reliable historical data, Nicholl notes that the phrase ‘in the east’ (Matthew 2:2, 9) probably refers to the star’s heliacal rising (i.e. rising just before the Sun). To the Magi, whom Nicholl assumes were experienced Babylonian astronomers, this would have held special significance.

He also assumes that, because of the Jewish community in Babylonia at the time of Jesus’ birth, the Magi would also have been aware of Messianic prophecies in the Old Testament.

Having dismissed several previous theories, Nicholl uses Revelation 12:1-5 to build his own comet hypothesis. Whilst accepting this Revelation passage as prophecy depicting cosmic spiritual warfare involving Israel (God’s people), Satan and Christ, he also relates it to a ‘celestial drama’, vividly depicting Christ’s birth as it took place for the benefit of experienced sky-watchers familiar with Hebrew Messianic prophecies.

Specifically, he links the woman (Revelation 12:1) with the zodiacal constellation of Virgo and the dragon (12:3) with the nearby constellation of Hydra (the water serpent). The Christ-child (12:4-5) is represented by Nicholl’s proposed spectacular comet, whose movements and changes in appearance within Virgo depict the birth of Christ.

Nicholl relates the stars flung to the Earth in Revelation 12:4 to a postulated meteor storm, whose radiant (the apparent origin of the meteors) was close to Hydra’s tail.

Assuming that Jesus was born around 6 BC, Nicholl takes the reference to the Sun and Moon in Revelation 12:1 to describe a specific sky configuration. Using modern planetarium software, he dates this as 15 September 6 BC, deducing that the Magi arrived in Bethlehem around the end of November.

The comet would then have had a long, striking tail and, as they approached Bethlehem on the road from Jerusalem, it could thus have ‘pointed out’ the house where Jesus and his mother were.

Nicholl’s hypothesis has been constructed with careful scholarship. However, there are some important caveats. There are no contemporary records of a comet around 6 BC fitting his detailed description. To counter this objection, he estimates that about two thirds of observable comets of the time, even bright ones, would have gone unrecorded. But given his claim that this was ‘the greatest comet in history’, this defence looks unconvincing.

Nicholl also dismisses the idea that the Star of Bethlehem was supernatural, even though there are numerous cases in Scripture of objective supernatural events. Nicholl’s dismissal of the supernatural is unjustified.

Nicholl’s idea that an astronomical drama guided the Magi to the infant Christ comes perilously close to the ‘Gospel in the stars’ concept popularised in the nineteenth century by Joseph A. Seiss and E. W. Bullinger. This implies that the stars can serve as an alternative source of revelation to Scripture, an idea rightly eschewed by most conservative evangelicals.

Nicholl develops his case by interpreting historical probabilities in plausible ways, yet this approach cannot exclude alternatives. It is impossible to achieve certainty in such an exercise. All this means that his claim to have solved ‘the age-old mystery of the Star of Bethlehem’ (p.27) is unjustified. The book is compelling and highly informative, yet it remains speculation.

William Worraker


Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Why Should I Trust the Bible?

We should trust the Bible, says Timothy Paul Jones, because it is ‘grounded in the words of a man who died and rose again’ (p.111). Jones’s basic presupposition is this: ‘If we live in a world where it is possible…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Who Am I? Human Identity and the Gospel in a Confusing World
Thomas Fretwell

In today’s secular society, religion is often regarded as without rational or scientific basis, and therefore irrelevant to life in the modern world and all areas of public engagement. If that is our social context, then it is no wonder…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Pastor’s Life: Practical Wisdom from the Puritans
Matthew D Haste & Shane W Parker

This book highlights ‘some of the many lessons that today’s pastors can learn from the Puritans’ (p.151). As such it is aimed at pastors, but the lessons are really for anyone who is a Christian leader. The opening chapter provides…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
5 Minutes in Church History: An Introduction to the Stories of God’s Faithfulness in the History of the Church
Stephen J Nichols

What a breath of fresh air this book is! Stephen Nichols has given us 40 vignettes from church history that are brief enough to be digested over a bowl of cereal. The book doesn’t aim to be a beginner’s guide…