Subscribe now

Daddy tried: overcoming the failures of fatherhood

by Tim Bayly
May 2017 | Review by Sheila Stephen
  • Publisher: Warhorn Publishing
  • ISBN: 978-1-940017-09-9
  • Pages: 208
  • Price: 0.00

With good reason, theologian John Frame calls this ‘the best book on fathering currently in print’. Tim Bayly is an American pastor with over 30 years’ experience. He addresses fatherhood in the home, church and public square, with application to fathers, ministers and all men.

Daddy tried begins with ‘Fatherhood lost’, rooting the sad state of fatherhood today in fatherhood’s first failure: Adam’s fall. Amid these opening chapters, the foundation for repentance is laid — to see our sin not in a vague, general sense, but in the particulars of daily life.

Bayly writes: ‘Of course we can choose to go to a church where the pastor never forces us to look at our teeth and our gums, where he never requires us to have an endoscopy or to get on the examining table. But what’s the use? Where will that get us — sitting under a preacher who never preaches to our sin and our conscience’ (p.34).

The next section, ‘Fatherhood redeemed’, patterns true fatherhood on God the Father. It focuses on God’s love, discipline and jealousy. Bayly outlines the tenderness of a father’s love and opens our eyes to the various ways God’s fatherly discipline is despised in the world today.

‘Fatherhood restored’ is the next theme, analysing practical details of fatherhood. In a chapter on marital fruitfulness, Bayly brings a much-needed breath of fresh air to the widespread antipathy today towards the hard work of having and raising children, bringing the Bible to bear on this little-discussed topic at the heart of fatherhood.

The book continues with some practical wisdom on household discipline. This is tremendously helpful, because, by and large, Christian fathers have forgotten how to bring fatherly discipline to their sons and daughters. It was this chapter, a young father told me, that stood out to him most.

Next, fathers are addressed concerning the instruction of their children. Priority is given to training in the ways of God above all other pursuits, such as education or career success.

After a chapter on fatherly love, Tim Bayly speaks to church fathers: pastors, elders, deacons, Sunday school teachers and the like. He focuses on two aspects of fatherhood: discipline and tender affection. On discipline he writes: ‘I fear our talk of grace and parallel neglect of discipline are too often the products of our aversion to conflict, our fear of a drop in attendance and giving, and our dread of dismissal’ (p.146).

Following this is a chapter on city fathers. Tim Bayly’s love for his own father shines through, with some precious examples of the godly work of fathers in the public square. The concluding section, ‘Fatherhood and failure’, ends with a chapter entitled ‘He failed gloriously’, encouraging fathers not to be dismayed at their failures.

If would-be readers fear that this book will strike some raw nerves, then take hope. As the subtitle implies, it is written for failures! It packs a weighty punch, but comes with a deep sense of hope and encouragement for men to look to God, who grants the courage and resources to obey.

Henry Milewski


Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
John James

For bright young things contemplating a call to pastoral ministry, church planting is where it’s at. Alternatively, service in an already large and thriving work is often pursued. Why bother trying to turn around a dying church when you can…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
With Mercy and with Judgement
Matthew J Hyde

Much attention is being paid to World War 1 and it is important to study its impact on Christians. The Strict Baptists were a relatively small denomination in 1914, but Dr Matthew Hyde’s study gives illuminating insight into the impact…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Jonathan Edwards & Transatlantic Print Culture
Jonathan Yeager

This is a must-read for every Edwards aficionado. It is a treasure trove of eighteenth-century publishing and the activities of booksellers. Some might be tempted to dismiss the garnered facts as mere minutiae, but we soon capture the theme undergirding…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
A Scenic Route through the Old Testament
Alec Motyer

This is a new edition of a book originally published in 1994. I am pleased that it has been made available again. Many people, particularly new or young Christians, find the Old Testament daunting. They find it difficult to piece…