Subscribe now

The crisis of evangelical Christianity: roots, consequences and resolutions

by Keith Sewell
July 2017 | Review by Colin Hamer
  • Publisher: Wipf and Stock
  • ISBN: 978-1498238755
  • Pages: 308
  • Price: 25.00

Keith Sewell (Professor of history at Dordt College, Iowa) brings his extensive knowledge of the history of Christianity to an assessment of evangelicalism today.

He points out the early and ubiquitous influence of Platonism on the post-apostolic church. He remarks how ‘notions of holiness consisting in a constant abstemiousness with respect to ordinary, creaturely existence ran counter to the main thrust of biblical teaching, with its strong, creation affirming orientation’ (p.21). This perspective was, he believes, only partially refuted in the Reformation.

He analyses several strands in the Reformation. He believes that Calvin’s eschewal of a ‘false literalism’ was faithful to a true understanding of Scripture. He also believes that Calvin’s concern for the wider implications of biblical principles and the state of the culture in which he was living were steps in the right direction. However, Sewell avers that the Reformation was only a start and that evangelicals should be ‘always reforming’.

While not denying John Wesley’s Herculean evangelistic efforts, he believes that his version of a subjective, pietistic Christianity was rooted in Platonism. From it (and other influences) came second-experience theology, individualism and, ultimately, the Charismatic movement.

He argues for a cessationist position regarding miraculous spiritual gifts, while pointing out that ‘the term is regrettable … [it] should not be misrepresented as disbelief in the Holy Spirit … nor does it amount to a disavowal of the miraculous’ (p.97). He critiques ‘third wave’ Charismatic influence and the use of worship groups to lead the congregation. He suggests, ‘Few evangelicals know enough of the history of Christianity to adequately understand their present predicament’ (p.172).

He believes there has been an intellectual deficit within evangelicalism that caused it to be caught out by the rise of Higher Criticism. More controversially for many evangelicals, while he supports an understanding of the infallibility of Scripture, he does not accept the old Princeton position of inerrancy: he believes that many have been over-zealous in looking for literal interpretations of Genesis 1-11, and suggests that, if intelligent design (ID) ‘is to prove the existence of God, then ID fails because the God revealed in the Bible is the Creator of all things, including the laws of logic, to which he is not subject’ (p.165).

He criticises what he calls the ‘double reductionism of evangelicalism’. As he sees it, we have reduced everything to church and missions, and then made a further reduction by preaching a gospel that is largely confined to an individual and personal salvation.

In contrast, he believes there should be an emphasis on seeing the full-orbed nature of God’s creation and a Christian’s part in it. He comments, ‘Some might decry this as the sacralisation of the secular, or the secularisation of the sacred, but that is to introduce false dichotomies, extrinsic to the Bible’ (pp.204-5).

Sewell’s grasp of his subject is impressive. However, the wealth of material he presents to support his thesis might overwhelm some, including busy pastors. This is a pity, because I think there is much to be gained from his insights.

Colin Hamer

Warrington

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Read Mark Learn – Luke Vol 1
William Taylor

These are study notes on Luke chapters 1-9. They are intended for use by small groups, but could be used for personal study. They are taken from sermons preached by the author, who is the rector at St Helen’s Bishopsgate,…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Daddy tried: overcoming the failures of fatherhood
Tim Bayly

(5 Star) With good reason, theologian John Frame calls this ‘the best book on fathering currently in print’. Tim Bayly is an American pastor with over 30 years’ experience. He addresses fatherhood in the home, church and public square, with…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Born Slaves – The Bondage of the Will
Martin Luther

This is an excellent introduction to an essential doctrine, sadly, opposed by John Wesley and many professed evangelicals. Luther states clearly in the preface, ‘Man is born a slave to sin! He is not free’. He then goes on to…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
How can I practice Christian Meditation
Joel Beeke

The 21st century is witness to an information revolution not seen since the invention of the printing press. The challenge for Christians today, faced with vast amounts of images, news feeds, social media and web surfing, is to keep all…