Subscribe now

Evolution: still a theory in crisis

By Michael Denton
December 2017 | Review by Colin Hamer
  • Publisher: Discovery Institute
  • ISBN: 978-1936599325
  • Pages: 354
  • Price: 16.80
Buy this book »

Michael Denton is a British-Australian biochemist. This book is an update of his 1985 title, Evolution: a theory in crisis.

 It contains many technical terms and more than 800 endnotes, referencing academic works in support of his thesis. However, the written style is clear, as is the book’s message that Darwinian evolution is like, as Denton says, the queen in Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland — believing in six impossible things before breakfast (p.225).

Denton believes that there are evolutionary processes demonstrated in nature, and does not argue for a Creator nor even intelligent design. But he does point out that living organisms belong to distinct taxa (such as fish, reptiles, primates) and that Darwinian evolution (teaching that innovations are the result of many gradual changes over long periods of time, driven by the need to survive) cannot explain their origin.

He further demonstrates that taxa often have astonishingly complex and interrelated features that need to be ‘right first time’ and cannot be explained by gradual steps. He comments: ‘Incongruous though it may seem … especially to a reader outside of academia … it remains true that the vast majority of all taxa are indeed defined by novelties without any antecedent in any presumed ancestral forms’ (p.56).

What is more, he points out that many such novelties serve no apparent survival function at all, thus not conforming to any Darwinian ‘survival of the fittest’ concept. Male nipples, he believes, are an example.

Furthermore, he points to a ‘third infinity’ that modern biology has revealed: ‘Stunning complexity is everywhere in current biology [a complexity Darwin could never have even imagined] … the cosmos is an infinity of the very large, and the atom is the infinity of the very small’. But the ‘organism is the infinity of the very complex. That such an infinity might have come about in finite time, as a result of any undirected random process, seems impossible’.

On nearly every page, Denton gives examples of the extraordinary complexity of living organisms: ‘Between a living cell and the most highly ordered non-biological system … there is a chasm as vast and absolute as it is possible to conceive’ (p.121). A chasm, he believes, it is impossible for any imagined evolutionary process to bridge.

I have read several helpful books from within the Christian community on the creation/evolution debate. But this book is truly remarkable and would richly reward any reader interested in the subject, even if, like myself, they do not have a relevant scientific background to engage in the detail of Denton’s arguments. Buy it, read it, and then lend it to another!

Colin Hamer

Warrington

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Counsel to Gospel Ministers
John Brown

John Brown of Haddington (1722-1787) was one of the great ministers of the Scottish church during a dark period in her history. As a pastor, divinity professor and writer he did much for the spiritual good of his native land.…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
All you need to know about the Bible – Book 5
Brian H Edwards

This informative book is a joy to read and of great importance in restoring the confidence of the ordinary Christian in the Word of God. It is one of a set of six short books with the same title, All…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Trinity and the covenant of redemption
J. V. Fesko

Dr Fesko is a professor at Westminster Seminary in California. This Mentor book is the first of a proposed series of three, aimed at retrieving the classic Reformed doctrine of covenants. This project should meet enthusiastic approval, following current debates…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Cornerstones of Salvation
Lee Gatiss

The title of this book quotes a phrase used in the text just three pages from the end. In a chapter examining John Wesley’s campaigns against Calvinism, Dr Gatiss warns that adulation for Wesley, merely on the grounds God used…