Subscribe now

Can We Trust the Gospels?

By Peter J. Williams
March 2019 | Review by Paul Smith
  • Publisher: Crossway Books
  • ISBN: 978-1-43355-295-3
  • Pages: 160
  • Price: 10.99
Buy this book »

This is almost unique as an apologetic resource. Christians usually must choose between big books which are scholarly or popular books which are simplistic. This book presents robust arguments that ordinary people can follow.

In eight digestible chapters Williams serves up the cream of recent apologetics on the gospels. He does not attack straw men or fight yesterday’s apologetic battles. Being both Bible scholar and personal evangelist, Williams knows the kind of objections currently heard on the streets, or popularised on Youtube. He not only rebuts the scepticism of men like Bart Ehrman but exposes flaws in their reasoning, demonstrating that it is the sceptic who is on the back foot.

Williams makes a simple case: ‘that the Gospels display signs that would normally be taken as indications of reliability’ (p.132). The core of the book (chapters 2-5) demonstrates that the Gospels have the hallmarks of authentic historical writing. One chapter surveys incidental details of geography and the way that the Gospels clarify common names (e.g. Simon the Leper) whilst rare ones (e.g. Bartholomew) don’t need such ‘disambiguators’.

Williams also deals head-on with recent favourites amongst sceptics: that the biblical text has been changed and that we have the words of the disciples, not the words of Jesus. As a leading scholar in biblical languages, the words of the Director of Tyndale House, Cambridge, carry authority.

Crucially, Williams does not set out to prove that the gospels are true. Rather he argues that, with so much evidence in their favour, it is people’s prior convictions (e.g. that miracles can’t happen) that lead them to resort to any argument, however implausible, to dismiss the Gospels. Williams begins to press this home in the final chapter which helps keep his audience reading.

Can we Trust the Gospels? is useful for sceptic and believer alike. Unusually, it is a book I will unreservedly recommend to any sceptic from sixth form upwards. Its tone is measured and respectful, refreshingly free of rhetorical flourishes.

It is also highly recommended for believers. First, it provides encouragement by demonstrating that even by the standards and methods of the secular academy it requires highly speculative hypothesising to explain away the Gospels. Second, it models how to engage the sceptic. Discussing non-christian sources, for example, Williams does not give fine-sounding but easily-rebutted general statistics. He carefully shows what can and cannot be proved, thereby increasing the credibility of his case.

My appetite having been whetted by Williams’ lectures on apologetics, I’ve been awaiting such a book for years. Buy multiple copies. It’s an apologetic goldmine.

Paul Smith

Broadstairs

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Preacher’s Catechism
Lewis Allen

Lewis Allen has evidently thought long and hard about the nature of the Christian ministry. The result is The Preacher’s Catechism, a collection of 43 questions and answers which bring essential truths to the preacher’s heart. Loosely following the structure…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Evolution and the Christian Faith. Theistic evolution in the light of scripture (Creation Points)
Philip Bell

The creation / evolution debate still rages, and many Christians believe it is both scientifically untenable and scripturally naïve to accept a literal account of the beginning of Genesis. Some even charge creationists with pushing a teaching that is a…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
New Covenant Theology: Weighed and Found Wanting
Kevin McGrane

To read this book was like a breath of fresh air. I could not put it down. Despite the traction that has been gained in the UK among evangelicals by the so-called ‘new covenant theology’ (NCT), it is surprising that…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Strength for the Weary
Derek W H Thomas

Are you weary, fellow pilgrims? Then let the ordained writer, Isaiah, speak to you in graphic terms through Dr Thomas, especially from chapters 40-46. Upon receipt of this book, I soon became engrossed. In keeping with its title, my own…