Subscribe now

Christless Christianity: The Alternative Gospel of the American Church

By Michael Horton
June 2009 | Review by Anthony Oughton

Synopsis

Is it possible that we have left Christ out of Christianity? Is the faith and practice of American Christians today more American than Christian? These are the provocative questions Michael Horton addresses in this thoughtful, insightful book. He argues that while we invoke the name of Christ, too often Christ and the Christ-centred gospel are pushed aside. The result is a message and a faith that are, in Horton's words, 'trivial, sentimental, affirming, and irrelevant'. This alternative 'gospel' is a message of moralism, personal comfort, self-help, self-improvement, and individualistic religion. It trivialises God, making him a means to our selfish ends. Horton skilfully diagnoses the problem and points to the solution: a return to the unadulterated gospel of salvation.

  • Publisher: Baker Books
  • ISBN: 978-0801013188
  • Pages: 240
  • Price: £8.00
Buy this book »

Book Review

Michael Horton is a seminary professor, magazine editor, talk-show host and prolific author. His latest book, Christless Christianity, is dedicated to ‘our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom we have now received reconciliation’ (Romans 5:11).

The antithesis between the dedication and the title nicely captures Horton’s point – whereas biblical Christianity is about Christ’s mediation between sinners and a holy God, the American church is trying to bypass Christ to meet God half-way and on its own terms. Like Christianity and Liberalism by J. Gresham Machen, Christless Christianity pulls few punches, preferring the way of stark contrasts instead.

Horton identifies Pelagianism (in one form or another) as a ‘default position’ to which we continually revert – a fact that leads some preachers to drift into ‘Law Lite’. For example, Joel Osteen is quoted as saying, ‘I know I’m not perfect, but … I’m doing my best to please Him’. This is followed up by further law in place of the gospel, which takes the form of ‘good advice’ in place of ‘Good News’.

Horton critiques therapeutic moralism, rampant individualism, gnosticism and subjectivism – directing us away from asking, ‘What would Jesus do?’ to contemplate ‘What has Jesus done?’ He presents this emphasis as the antidote to the legacy of Charles Finney, which includes Willow Creek methodology and social activism. He calls instead for a church that will proclaim the everlasting gospel, dispense the sacraments (there is an apologetic for a Reformed view of the Lord’s Supper) and exercise discipline.

Horton repeats some of the work of David Wells on therapeutic and narcissistic culture, although he builds on this to provide an accessible, church-focussed response. It would be good for him to have interacted with ministers like Tim Keller who perhaps would see the church’s mission in broader terms.

It might be argued that Horton is too negative about experience and some readers may not share his fondness for non-evangelical sources of wisdom. Finally there is the question of how relevant the book can be to the British church.

However, this is a satisfying, challenging and even exciting analysis and call to ‘resistance’, making the effort to translate it into our own setting surely worthwhile.

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Why Should I Trust the Bible?

We should trust the Bible, says Timothy Paul Jones, because it is ‘grounded in the words of a man who died and rose again’ (p.111). Jones’s basic presupposition is this: ‘If we live in a world where it is possible…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Who Am I? Human Identity and the Gospel in a Confusing World
Thomas Fretwell

In today’s secular society, religion is often regarded as without rational or scientific basis, and therefore irrelevant to life in the modern world and all areas of public engagement. If that is our social context, then it is no wonder…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Pastor’s Life: Practical Wisdom from the Puritans
Matthew D Haste & Shane W Parker

This book highlights ‘some of the many lessons that today’s pastors can learn from the Puritans’ (p.151). As such it is aimed at pastors, but the lessons are really for anyone who is a Christian leader. The opening chapter provides…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
5 Minutes in Church History: An Introduction to the Stories of God’s Faithfulness in the History of the Church
Stephen J Nichols

What a breath of fresh air this book is! Stephen Nichols has given us 40 vignettes from church history that are brief enough to be digested over a bowl of cereal. The book doesn’t aim to be a beginner’s guide…