Subscribe now

Ten Myths about Calvinism

By Kenneth J Stewart
October 2011 | Review by Anthony Oughton

Synopsis

Historian of Christianity Ken Stewart is intent on setting the record straight about Reformed theology. He identifies ten myths held by either or both Calvinists and non-Calvinists and shows how they are gross mischaracterizations of that theological stream. Certain of these persistent stereotypes that defy historical research often present a truncated view of the depth and breadth of the Reformed tradition. Others, although erroneous, are nevertheless used to dismiss outright this rich body of biblical theological teaching.

  • Publisher: IVP (Apollos)
  • ISBN: 978-1-84474-513-5
  • Pages: 304
  • Price: 14.99
Buy this book »

Book Review

The main title, ‘Ten Myths About Calvinism’, suggests a strident volume in which opposing views will be given short shrift. In fact, this is a balanced and scholarly work, though accessible to the general reader.

      The book is organised into two parts. Part one deals with ‘Four Myths Calvinists Should Not Be Circulating (But Are)’. These are: One Man (Calvin) and One City (Geneva) Are Determinative, Calvin’s View of Predestination Must be Ours, TULIP is the Yardstick of the Truly Reformed, and Calvinists Take a Dim View of Revival.

      In chapter one, emphasis is placed on the plurality of Reformation leaders such as Bullinger, Zwingli, and Peter Martyr, and of places such as Zurich, Basel and Strasbourg. The pre-eminence of Calvin is reckoned a nineteenth century phenomenon, associated with Romanticism and the decision of one Henry Drummond to finance the reprinting of ‘The Institutes’. While this is interesting historically, it’s unlikely to convince those who see God’s providence behind the wide dissemination of Calvin’s great work. The author perhaps could have interacted with the view of scholar Philip Benedict that Calvin, ‘unquestionably merits the leading role traditionally assigned him’. Likewise in the TULIP chapter, where the acrostic is again said to be a late and unsatisfactory development, Lorraine Boettner could have been more extensively dealt with rather than footnoted.

      Part Two is on the face of it more likely to appeal to staunch Calvinists, with its ‘Six Myths Non-Calvinists Should Not Be Circulating (But Are)’, which comprise: Calvinism is Largely Antimissionary, Calvinism Promotes Antinomianism, Calvinism Leads to Theocracy, Calvinism Undermines the Creative Arts, Calvinism Resists Gender Equality, and Calvinism Has Fostered Racial Inequality. Chapter five should appeal to many, and the remaining chapters adopt strategies of showing that just because Calvinism has been associated with questionable practices, this does not mean it has caused them, or that Calvinism is no more tainted than any other tradition.

      The chapter on the arts admits varying degrees of iconoclasm, but shows how the Reformation began to support a new kind of art as it developed, although more could be said about our current situation regarding the arts.

      On women, we are told Calvin approved of women deacons for distributing alms, and are introduced to various ‘church mothers’.

      The book is well written and purposeful in its explicit aim of ‘Recovering Our Bearings’. While some will find it controversial, it is a thought provoking volume.

 

Anthony Oughton,

Gateshead

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Why Should I Trust the Bible?

We should trust the Bible, says Timothy Paul Jones, because it is ‘grounded in the words of a man who died and rose again’ (p.111). Jones’s basic presupposition is this: ‘If we live in a world where it is possible…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Who Am I? Human Identity and the Gospel in a Confusing World
Thomas Fretwell

In today’s secular society, religion is often regarded as without rational or scientific basis, and therefore irrelevant to life in the modern world and all areas of public engagement. If that is our social context, then it is no wonder…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Pastor’s Life: Practical Wisdom from the Puritans
Matthew D Haste & Shane W Parker

This book highlights ‘some of the many lessons that today’s pastors can learn from the Puritans’ (p.151). As such it is aimed at pastors, but the lessons are really for anyone who is a Christian leader. The opening chapter provides…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
5 Minutes in Church History: An Introduction to the Stories of God’s Faithfulness in the History of the Church
Stephen J Nichols

What a breath of fresh air this book is! Stephen Nichols has given us 40 vignettes from church history that are brief enough to be digested over a bowl of cereal. The book doesn’t aim to be a beginner’s guide…