In an age shaped by hot takes, comment threads, and quick exits, we have forgotten how to disagree well. Too often, disagreement is treated as disloyalty. Someone else’s view is no longer just another view, instead it becomes a threat. A secondary issue becomes a dividing wall, and before long, distance replaces dialogue. But healthy communities are not built on uniformity of opinion. They are built on shared allegiance to Christ, patient love, and a commitment to remain at the table even when we see things differently.
Where do we disagree?
Christians disagree in many areas, such as theology (e.g. eschatology, baptism), worship styles, political engagement, public policy, leadership decisions – the list is long. Some disagreements involve core doctrines – the person of Christ, the authority of Scripture, the gospel itself. These are foundational. But many disagreements live in the category Scripture itself treats as disputable matters.
The apostle Paul addressed such tensions among the church in Rome, urging believers not to quarrel over secondary issues but to welcome one another as Christ has welcomed them. Not every disagreement is a reason for division. And certainly not every disagreement is grounds for excommunication.
— This article continues for ET members
