Subscribe now

A Sad Departure

By David J Randall
July 2016 | Review by Gavin Beers
  • Publisher: Banner of Truth Trust
  • ISBN: 978-1-84871-661-2
  • Pages: 206
  • Price: 7.50
Buy this book »

Book Review

Written by a former Church of Scotland minister, this is an account of the secession of 40 ministers from that church due to the acceptance of homosexuality in its ordained ministry.

It is graciously written and far from triumphalist. It is more a lament on behalf of those who reluctantly left the denomination, as well as for the denomination itself that has tragically departed from the Word of God.

A concise review of events and decisions of recent General Assemblies is presented. This includes the climactic decisions of 2013-2015, which reaffirmed the historical teaching of the Church of Scotland on human sexuality, while leaving it open to individual congregations to ignore this if desired. Astonishingly, this self-contradictory proposal was made by a professing evangelical.

Readers will appreciate Mr Randall’s clear defence of biblical authority and teaching on homosexuality. The final chapter records testimonies of ministers who did leave, affording a window into their struggles.

The author’s central aim is to defend their secession. An explanation is also given as to why they remained in the denomination until that point. The argument is that even though there were unbiblical practices in the church and false doctrine was taught, the church itself had not sanctioned these at its Assembly or formally rejected the Bible. But that line was crossed when the General Assembly affirmed the teaching of Scripture on homosexuality and, in the same breath, decreed that congregations could ignore it.

While sympathetic to those who have chosen the difficult path of secession; yet gladdened by their conviction to stand on principle, and mourning with them the departure of the Church of Scotland from the Word of God, readers may find weaknesses in aspects of the argument.

For example, 15 of the 40 men who left did so before 2013 when the above proposal was made to the General Assembly. This highlights a diversity of opinion and lack of concerted action or direction.

Moreover, the plain teaching of Scripture on the ordination of women has been officially rejected by the church courts for many decades, but there is little engagement with this issue in the book. The failure of William Still’s ‘quiet infiltration’ method for evangelical, denominational renewal is also evident.

The book’s concern for the lack of church discipline over homosexuality raises the uncomfortable question of why evangelicals in previous years were unwilling to pursue discipline against other public denials of cardinal truths of the Christian faith. 

This is a significant work on a contemporary Christian scandal. It gives readers insight to a tragic period in the church’s history. We pray God’s blessing on those who have taken this stand and that he will give the same spirit to others still in a ‘broad’ church.

Gavin Beers

Hollybush, Ayrshire

Book Reviews

Read our latest book reviews

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Why Should I Trust the Bible?

We should trust the Bible, says Timothy Paul Jones, because it is ‘grounded in the words of a man who died and rose again’ (p.111). Jones’s basic presupposition is this: ‘If we live in a world where it is possible…

See all book reviews
Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
Who Am I? Human Identity and the Gospel in a Confusing World
Thomas Fretwell

In today’s secular society, religion is often regarded as without rational or scientific basis, and therefore irrelevant to life in the modern world and all areas of public engagement. If that is our social context, then it is no wonder…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
The Pastor’s Life: Practical Wisdom from the Puritans
Matthew D Haste & Shane W Parker

This book highlights ‘some of the many lessons that today’s pastors can learn from the Puritans’ (p.151). As such it is aimed at pastors, but the lessons are really for anyone who is a Christian leader. The opening chapter provides…

Star RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar RatingStar Rating
5 Minutes in Church History: An Introduction to the Stories of God’s Faithfulness in the History of the Church
Stephen J Nichols

What a breath of fresh air this book is! Stephen Nichols has given us 40 vignettes from church history that are brief enough to be digested over a bowl of cereal. The book doesn’t aim to be a beginner’s guide…